The Will of God
category: Jims Guatemala

You know how to push-start a car is, right? In cars with manual transmissions, you can still start them if the battery is dead. Put the car in first gear, hold the clutch out, get a few strong guys to push it until it starts to roll, then pop the clutch. The impulse from the transmission turns the engine over, and gives enough spark through the ignition system to fire it up. Why am I telling you this? Because on our long, long trip back to our village today, I saw a dozen guys push-start a diesel bus that way in the terminal. I laughed out loud; that’s so Guatemala. My laugh caught in my throat when I realized it was MY bus they started.

Spending hours on a bus gives me time to ponder our work here, and the parallels it has with things in the U.S. I read a story in the news this morning about an 11-year-old American girl that died in her home because her parents denied her medical care. She was diabetic, and slipped into an insulin-induced coma. The parents are extremist Christians, and refused to take her to the hospital because they couldn’t “put doctors before God,” they said. Instead, they gathered the family around and prayed for days, as their child slowly and surely died. Now they’re up for manslaughter.

As shocking and unfortunate as this is, it chills me even more because we deal with this problem all the time here in Guatemala. During our second month in Guatemala, a neighbor’s son-in-law was decapitated in a horrific traffic accident. Everyone shook their heads, muttering that it was the voluntad de dios (the will of God). It never occurred to anyone that it might have POSSIBLY been because he was totally drunk and driving on the busiest highway in Guatemala. It was voluntad de dios last month, when the lady on the other side of the village died in childbirth, despite the fact that they didn’t take her to the hospital, even though she showed several of the high-risk danger signs. And the voluntad de dios nearly killed Galindo as he lay dying next door, until the “voluntad de Nas Palas” saved his life.

I like to delude myself into thinking that we as Americans are above a lot of the third-world, hillbilly, backwater things that inflict Guatemala. But the truth is, these things happen in the U.S. too. The only difference is a matter of scale. Organized religion has a lot to offer mankind; but blind, unreasoning devotion to ANYTHING fosters ignorance and paves the way to disaster. We tell people that the good Lord helps those who help themselves, but many of them don’t listen. It reminds me of a joke:

There was once a devout man who was the only survivor of a shipwreck. After floating a day at sea, he came to rest upon a small deserted island. He immediately got down on his knees to give thanks that he was spared, then prayed to God to deliver him from his captivity. “God will help me escape this island,” the man thought to himself.

A few days later, a boat came by, and offered to take him to their next port. “No thank you,” the man said. “I asked God to save me, and he will come.”

A few more days passed, and water was running low. The man heard a noise in the distance, and soon a helicopter swooped low over the island. “We’ve come to save you,” the pilot yelled through a bullhorn. The man waved the helicopter off, yelling, “I asked God to save me, and he will come.”

On the seventh day, the man was lying thirsty on the beach and near death. He shook the fog from his head, and saw a man step out of hot air balloon and walk towards him.

“Ye gads man, you look awful. Let’s get you into this balloon, and be off,” the balloonist said.

The man weakly raised his hand, shooing the balloonist away. “I asked God to save me, and he will come.”

The following day, the devout man died. He ascended to heaven, as devout men do, and encountered Saint Peter at the gate.

“Excuse me,” the devout man said, hesitantly. “I couldn’t help but wonder. I’ve put my faith in God all my life, and He has always been there for me through good and bad. But when I prayed for Him to deliver me from the desert island, he forsook me. Why? I still had much to do in my life, and my children will now never know what happened to me.”

Saint Peter looked up from his book, perplexed, and pulled down his reading glasses. “What are you talking about? We sent a boat, a helicopter, and even a balloon!”

Think about it.


UPDATE

I just got this from my friend Karen; it’s a link to a fantastic (and short) article in the New York Times on EXACTLY this theme. Perhaps Karen is prescient. I read it, and was dismayed at how Pakistan is so much like Guatemala.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/30/opinion/30kristof.html?_r=1

Posted by: jfanjoy



Hide Comments
  1. Belkar posted the following on August 3, 2009 at 8:54 am.

    James,

    That is a great post. We are having issues on faith based denial of medical treatment here too. We will be having another trial, one was for a baby girl who died of a respiratory infection that could have been easily treated and the other is for a 17 year old boy who died of a urinary tract infection totally treatable. In both cases they were restricted from medical treatment due to parents faith.

    I think that parents shouldn’t be allowed to prevent medical treatment of serious medical conditions of minors, but everything is degrees. How much intervention for what situations. It is such a slippery slope, and there are too many people to police for beliefs, unless we enact my Belief as the one that all must follow. I will even make you head of security…

    The other issue is that religion does provide a lot of quality of life for many. I am too poor to afford the medical treatment my family needs, so I am going to start drinking or kill myself, or take out my frustration on them. I am to poor, but that is God’s will. I think that religion makes living through situation, which people may have little control of, easier. How do we know when their beliefs have gone to far? Usually only after it has gone too far.

    I haven’t come up with a great reason or understanding. I do believe in God, but not as one that is all powerful, or at least one that isn’t all enacting. I don’t believe in God’s will because it is too damaging for my interaction with life, but I can’t force that on others.

    It isn’t all good. It is a lot of crap, but we have to make our own best choices and keep on living. How we interact with others is our choice, but forcing issues never leads to a positive outcome.

    I am glad you are living through this. It is a situation that makes us more aware of the real world, and tends to make one less careless in you live your own life.

    Well so much for team Chaos…

    Reply to Belkar
  2. Brian Fahs posted the following on August 4, 2009 at 10:38 am.

    Theres a book (based on a sermon series) by Leslie Weatherhead that addresses this “Will of God” issue directly.

    http://www.amazon.com/Will-God-Leslie-D-Weatherhead/dp/0687456010/ref=ed_oe_p

    If you struggle with this issue, or want to think about “Bad things that happen to Good People” I suggest you find your local christian book store, or amazon and give it a read. Our Mens group focused on it a few years ago and I found it quite interesting.

    Brian

    Reply to Brian Fahs
    1. Jim posted the following on August 4, 2009 at 8:47 pm.

      Thanks, Brian. I just clicked the link, and that looks like a book I’d really like to read. I wish-listed it, so I can read it when I get back from Peace Corps (and can afford books again). I wouldn’t say I “struggle” with this issue, it’s just something I’ve noticed. Perhaps I’m not compassionate enough, but I often see things in a detached, clinical way.

      I came across another good article in the BBC today. The author spends some time talking about how the US, the most advanced nation in the world, is paradoxically beset by a strong dose of dark-age superstition and ignorance. Then he directly refers to the same case I spoke of. You can read it here:
      http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspondent/8176448.stm

      Reply to Jim
      1. Brian Fahs posted the following on August 5, 2009 at 12:07 pm.

        Let me know next time you expect someone in the US to send you a care package. The book is small (80 pages and maybe 3×5″ 1/4″ thick) I’ll mail the book to anyone in the US putting a package together for you. Otherwise, remind me when you get back and you can have my copy.

        Reply to Brian Fahs
        1. Jim posted the following on August 5, 2009 at 1:25 pm.

          My mom is coming to see us at the end of the month, you could send it to her. But only if you don’t want it back; books sometimes disappear here. :) That, or they end up in the sizeable Peace Corps library of donated books. Volunteers read a lot here. Either way, thanks for the offer. It’s very kind.

          Reply to Jim

Add a Comment